We Buy & Sell Sports Cards
At US Coin Trust, we're more than coins. We Buy, Sell, and Trade sports trading cards and sports collectibles. We're passionate collectors and trusted dealers of sports trading cards and collectibles, from iconic vintage stars to today’s biggest names in the game.
Whether you're a lifelong collector, new to the hobby, or just looking to cash in on your collection, visit Mike at our Oakhurst location.
Looking to sell sports cards? We buy baseball, basketball, football and hockey cards - from single valuable cards to entire collections. Whether you're selling vintage cards to modern stars, our expert Mike provides honest evaluations and competitive cash payouts.
What We Buy:
-
Baseball cards (Topps, Bowman, vintage & modern)
-
Basketball cards (rookie, graded cards, inserts)
-
Football cards (autographs, patch card, collections)
-
Hockey cards & complete sets
-
Graded Cards (PSA, BGS, SGC)
-
Autographed Memorabilia
-
Unopened Boxes and Packs
-
Complete Collections - large or small
Get a Free Appraisal Today - Call Mike at 732-695-6868
We Buy Sports Cards - Baseball, Basketball & More
We Sell Sports Cards & Collectibles
Searching for sports cards for sale near you?
We carry a rotating inventory of baseball, basketball, football, and hockey cards, including rare finds, graded cards and collector favorites.
-
Hall of Fame legends
-
Rare and high-grade rookie cards
-
Game-used and autographed items
-
Specialty inserts and chase cards
Whether you're hunting for that one missing piece or building your dream collection, we've got what you need.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Where can I sell sports cards near me?
A: Visit Mike at US Coin Trust Oakhurst, NJ for fast, in person evaluations and same day cash offers.
Q: How much are my sports cards worth?
A: Value depends on condition, rarity and demand. We provide free appraisals to determine market value.
Q: Do you buy entire collections?
A: Yes! We buy single, partial collections and full estates.
Sports Card FAQ
Should I get my sports cards graded?
Grading can significantly increase a card’s value—especially rare or high-condition rookie cards. Professional grading companies such as PSA, BGS, and SGC authenticate your card and assign a trusted grade that buyers rely on.
Are my cards from the 1980s and 1990s worth anything?
Many cards from the “junk wax era” were heavily mass-produced, so most have low value. However, specific rookie cards, error cards, or cards in top-tier graded condition can be more valuable.
What is the best way to store my sports cards?
Store your cards in penny sleeves and top loaders, or in protective graded holders. Keep them in a cool, dry environment away from sunlight to prevent fading, bending, and other damage.
How can I sell my sports cards?
You can sell cards online through marketplaces like COMC or eBay, as well as at local card shops, shows, and specialty auction houses. Reviewing recent sales helps you price your items competitively.
Have more questions? Explore all our FAQs and services to learn how we can help.
Only a limited selection of products is available here. For a wider variety, visit our eBay Store.
Our best inventory is available at our two retail locations in Oakhurst and Colts Neck.
Stop in or contact us directly for questions or inquiries about additional product types.